Welcome to Slice’s Pizza
At Slice’s Pizza, we celebrate the art of pizza-making with a passion that resonates throughout our inviting space in Selden, NY. Our journey began with a commitment to crafting authentic NYC-style slices, boasting perfectly thin crusts that are crisp yet tender. Alongside our classic and gourmet pizzas, we offer a diverse menu featuring baked dishes and delicious wraps, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Our friendly staff and vibrant atmosphere make every visit memorable, whether you're indulging in a casual meal or dining with family and friends. Join us for a slice of happiness—your taste buds will thank you!
Slice’s Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Very good Peter has a little flop but now it seems it's under new ownership will see if it's still the same. I'll try it this week and I'll leave a new review, but was good in the past very good taste the sauce the cheese was phenomenal The pizza was good but a little undercooked you'll have to ask for it a little while done
Nowadays getting a true NYC slice is hard to come by. Either it's too thick or the crust isn't thin enough or not cooked to a crisp. Living a little north and east, I'm only in Selden maybe once a month. So my wife and I said, the next time we are in Selden, we'd come here. So yesterday that's what we did. The pizza was perfectly thin and the crust was perfect. The pepperoni pinwheels had a little spice and great taste. Everything was great and not dripping in oil either. The prices were even better than most local places as well. We'll definitely be returning. Great job.
Although this is a pizza joint it is my absolute favorite place for a grilled chicken caeser wrap! Everything in the display always looks so good but trying to eat on the healthier side, wraps are my go to most of the time and this place does it right everytime! The wrap is so tasty and the chicken is always grilled to perfection and it's always so fresh tasting. I'm addicted to your wraps so please continue being the wrap slayer of the neighborhood! The service is also always so pleasant and friendly unlike a lot of the other pizza places in the immediate area.
First time here... I told my son he could get an Italian ice after my visit at Sky Tan next door..( by the way the best tanning salon ever) Family Fun little slice of happiness topped off with great olè Italian ices The Art Deco design is a sight for viewing ... Very pretty & bright Wills service was friendly fast and courteous We LOVED OUR FIRST VISIT
I stopped by for a quick slice , I've never been here before. The place is bright and clean with pleasant staff behind the counter. What's prompted me leaving this review was how PERFECT the slice was. Not. Thin crust, just a regular slice - but with a perfect slight crispness to the crust! I know it's hard to fuck-up a slice of pizza, but perfection is hard to achieve. Plenty of other slices with various meats are on display. Only improvement I would make is little labels to identify the slices. I'm just not that guy who wants to say: "What's that? And that? That? That?" Then again I DID skip the fancy slices for a perfect regular slice - so maybe don't change a thing!
Location
-
1198 Middle Country Rd Selden, NY 11784 United States Hotline: (631) 333-2900
Welcome to Slice’s Pizza, the quintessential destination for pizza lovers in Selden, NY. Located at 1198 Middle Country Rd, this charming eatery merges casual dining with the comfort of a warm and inviting atmosphere. With the recent change in ownership, there’s a renewed buzz in the air, leaving customers eager to see how this beloved spot continues to evolve.
Slice’s Pizza offers not just a meal, but a complete dining experience. Their utility services cater to a variety of needs, including delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, making it perfect for both casual hangouts and family gatherings. The restaurant is family-friendly, with a robust menu that accommodates kids and groups alike, and yes, you can bring your four-legged friends too with outdoor seating available.
- Delivery & Takeout Available
- Reservations Accepted
- Outdoor Seating for Sunning Days
- Gender-neutral Restrooms
- Wi-Fi Access
- On-site Parking
Now, let’s talk pizza. With an impressive lineup of options, including the classic Regular Pizza Pie, the indulgent Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza, and the unique Grandma Alla Vodka Pizza, there's something to satisfy every palate. Customers rave about the perfect thin crust—a balance of crunch and chewiness—that doesn't drown in grease. The pizza toppings are fresh and flavorful, striking just the right note for those who crave authenticity reminiscent of New York's street corners.
For those looking beyond pizza, Slice's offers a selection of mouth-watering calzones and rolls, including the delectable Cheese Calzone and Buffalo Chicken Roll, alongside a range of fresh salads, such as the refreshing Greek Salad and hearty Antipasto Salad. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring that they delight health-conscious diners and indulgents alike.
Testimonials from happy patrons further reflect the restaurant’s commitment to quality. A recent customer noted the “perfect slice” with a crisp crust that’s hard to achieve, while another was floored by the flavor of their grilled chicken Caesar wrap, highlighting the eatery’s versatility. Visitors also appreciated the friendly service, noting that the staff at Slice's enhance the overall dining experience with their welcoming demeanor.
In essence, Slice’s Pizza isn’t just another pizza joint. It’s a community hub where lasting memories are created over a shared love of food. So, the next time you find yourself near Selden, make sure to step in and treat your taste buds to a slice of pizza perfection.
For orders, call them at (631) 333-2900. Join the pie revolution at Slice’s Pizza – you won't regret it!
